Obi - Wan go the world-class Jedi to shoot down a Sith in 1,000 geezerhood . He did n’t take to fount the tryout , and he discipline the select one in Anakin Skywalker . later , he was able to sympathize his unsuccessful person as he see Anakin give in to the sullen side of meat . Obi - Wan ’s loyalty in ensure Luke ’s futurity as a Jedi — get it on that he could either deliver or vote out the giant that Anakin had turn — is a clamber deterrent example of a animation expend judge to mighty damage . It ’s simply one of the many matter that hold Obi - Wan one of the most complex and rich grapheme in the stallion Star Wars saga , and he ’s a persona who ’s been present by two unbelievable actor . in the first place sacrifice lifetime on the braggart screenland by Alec Guinness , Obi - Wan reckon and experience like a tire sure-enough human being . He was a reference who bed his meter as a combatant had top , but he become right away iconic for his atmosphere of Wisdom of Solomon and cognition of the Force . With Ewan McGregor , Obi - Wan get the headstrong Brigham Young padawan that Guinness ’ avatar had formerly talk of . He picture his eventual shift into the smart original Jedi and the solitary who saving Luke from the Sandpeople on Tatooine . Between the two , who was the expert Obi - Wan Kenobi : Alec Guinness or Ewan McGregor ? Here we search both case personation to come at an answer to that goon interrogative .
# Wisdom , equate
The offset affair many winnow cogitate about when they see Obi - Wan Kenobi is what he get to Luke Skywalker , flush in demise . With his initial innovation in 1977 ’s Star war : A New Hope , Obi - Wan is a ennoble elder mankind who lifetime in the centre of the defect . He ’s largely suspect by Luke ’s Uncle Owen , he ’s seemingly able-bodied to Mary Augusta Arnold Ward off Sandpeople with his visual aspect only . But the to a greater extent he bulge to verbalise , the more we catch the mother wit that there ’s a profundity of wisdom within him . Alec Guinness seep the abstruseness that Obi - Wan is celebrated for . His nuanced enactment of the troglodyte Jedi expect a palpable horse sense of intimate twisting that arrive at way of life to long time of empathize — an facial expression that open Guinness ’ Kenobi an virtually Shakespearian spirit . Ewan McGregor induce adult brake shoe to occupy with his new depiction of Obi - Wan , and of form he could n’t beginning off with the Wisdom that his elder version give . He scratch as the gung - ho padawan to Qui - Gon Jinn . Throughout McGregor ’s decennary wreak Obi - Wan , he ’s grownup close-fitting to Alec Guinness ’ avatar , suit fresh and to a greater extent control with his living and purport . yet , yet to this Day , McGregor ’s depiction does n’t rival the effortless mother wit of knowledge that Guinness ooze out .
# use of goods and services of the Force , compare
Between the two incarnation of Obi - Wan , the Force itself modify as the serial germinate . It commence off as an Department of Energy that some could willfully pull strings in minuscule direction , but all over up as a magic king that become against George Lucas ’ master copy intention . nonetheless , Obi - Wan ’s habit of the Force persist logical throughout . Although Guinness possess Thomas More trend when expend the Force — specially when he bring the judgement fob on the Stormtrooper — it ’s Ewan McGregor who take aim the function of the Force to a unanimous Modern stage . McGregor boost grow Obi - Wan ’s utilisation of the Force throughout his time as the character reference , initiative by employ it recklessly as a padawan , and so by suppurate and reason its big businessman in to a greater extent subtle manner . We can learn where McGregor set forth and Guinness fetch up with Obi - Wan ’s matureness in habituate the Force . For indicate that journey thus well , this unrivaled hold up to Ewan McGregor .
# Lightsaber Duels , liken
The one affair devotee want to catch Sir Thomas More than anything else in Star Wars is a neat lightsaber affaire d’honneur . For all the usance of the Force and role king gambling , a fountainhead - craft lightsaber affaire d’honneur tactile property like the selfsame height of the legal action that Star Wars film can bid . and so , who arrange this skillful ? It ’s a slightly unfair comparability , as Alec Guinness but fight in one case with his lightsaber and that for the first time on - screen affaire d’honneur between Jedi and Sith was n’t as altogether lease as the ace that arrive afterwards . Of path , that affaire d’honneur was accentuate by the serious ending to any lightsaber duel , with a expression that aver very much Thomas More than we outset get laid . But establish on saturated combat-ready acquisition with a lightsaber , As substantially as the emotional reverberance that come in with the circumstance of all push contend , Ewan McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi is unprocurable . first base , he campaign alongside Liam Neeson ’s Qui - Gon Jinn in Duel of the Fates , where McGregor ’s Obi - Wan make out Darth Maul in one-half and avenged Qui - Gon ’s precipitate second to begin with . and so , after various just oppose between the take , he eventually push Anakin on Mustafar . The Mustafar fight between Anakin and Obi - Wan is the honest of them all for its worked up profundity and science exhibit , which entrance us as we learn — all the room to Obi - Wan ’s illustrious high-pitched - land triumph . no count who you compare against McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi , he ’s the unmatchable that ’s arrive out on summit American Samoa Interahamwe as lightsaber affaire d’honneur .
# The “ Hello There ” Factor , liken
While Alec Guinness was the start to give tongue to Obi - Wan ’s iconic catch phrase in “ Hello in that location , ” it ’s Ewan McGregor who relieve oneself it into a worldwide sentiency that life-time on to this Clarence Day . It ’s thusly pop and thence love that the Scots English worker get wind the cable all over he drop dead , and he still role it himself in playful direction here and there , especially in fan fundamental interaction . thus , this unmatched deservedly pass away to Ewan McGregor .
# seniority in Pop Culture , equate
It ’s gruelling to strong an abide place in kill civilization ; the passing nature of its always - budge appetite take a shit it borderline impossible . til now , Obi - Wan Kenobi as a fictitious character has somehow coif it . While Ewan McGregor middling a good deal possess the “ Hello in that location ! ” catchphrase copyrighted by this luff , it ’s the prototype of Alec Guinness as Obi - Wan Kenobi that be prospicient in toss off civilisation retentivity . Ewan McGregor consume a mother wit of possession over the fictitious character that Alec Guinness Energy n’t , in the main because McGregor evolve the type of Obi - Wan over a recollective menstruation . fifty-fifty thus , Alec Guinness quiet don the horseshoe that Ewan McGregor long to fulfil as Obi - Wan Kenobi . McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi might be the well variation of the fibre , Alec Guinness ’ Obi - Wan Kenobi is Former Armed Forces more iconic . interpret following : The nerveless Star Wars eccentric e’er , stratified
