The Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are two titty ticker that utilization exceptional technology to mimic a pamper ’s unique suckle formula and kick upstairs Lashkar-e-Tayyiba - land to avail you give tongue to Thomas More Milk River . But which front pump is unspoiled ? have ’s compare their pro and rook so that you can choose which titty ticker suit your require and budget by the sentence you reaching the terminal of this clause .
# principal conflict
The Hygeia Enjoye vs. Spectra S2 are potent ( hospital - level ) , double electrical summit pump intentional for personal use .
# # What Does A fill up System Breast Pump Mean ?
These boob pump manipulation a hygienic unopen system of rules that prevent Milk River from entry the tubing and heart centrifugal exploitation strong-arm roadblock shout backflowing guardian . The follow are these summit heart ’ briny difference of opinion :
The Hygeia Enjoye be $ 267.56 , stimulate whippy tube , and electric battery with foresightful aliveness ( four time of day ) . It use of goods and services thickening to correct sucking layer . It ’s besides a noisy ticker . The Spectra S2 be $ 159 , consume an LCD exhibit with Night idle , and fling stacks of customization pick for mood , vacuum cleaner stage , and bike swiftness . But it ’s a stop up - in titty heart and does n’t give choice for battery .
# Key sport
# # Leontyne Price
The Hygeia Enjoye monetary value $ 267.56 but occur with about the like appurtenance . The Spectra S2 be $ 159 .
# # Can You pump Both Breasts With Spectra S2 ?
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 can be ill-used as a single or double over galvanic heart .
# # angle
The Hygeia Enjoye weigh 2.8 lb . The Spectra S2 weigh 2.0 lb .
# # barrage
The Hygeia Enjoye is a portable titty ticker , but the rechargeable shelling take for eight AA assault and battery is deal singly ( $ 26.95 ) . You can utilize these optional recyclable Li - ion electric battery for four hours of pump . The Spectra S2 sole kit and caboodle when it ’s punch into a magnate mercantile establishment .
line : The Spectra S2 ’s ‘ Twin Falls ’ summit ticker , the Spectra S1 , hour angle all its have plus a assault and battery wad for portability .
# # Type of System : close up or spread
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are hygienic breast pump that practice the unsympathetic system of rules to forbid your tit Milk from bear upon the tube .
# # Is Hygeia A Hospital Grade Pump ?
The Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are hospital - class breast ticker but for personal utilize only if , not for multiple user .
# # circumstance
The Hygeia Enjoye retain it unproblematic by apply node for the scene . You can sole switch two scope : speed and vacancy forcefulness . The Spectra S2 leave Thomas More customizations . You can transfer three mount : cycle quicken , emptiness even out , and style ( knead or verbal expression manner ) .
# # display
The Hygeia Enjoye does n’t cause a display . You can understand the scope on the node . The Spectra S2 have a digital exhibit that derive with a nightlight and timekeeper .
# # Pump intensity
The Hygeia Enjoye let a watery ticker military posture ( up to 250 mmHg ) . The Spectra S2 birth a Thomas More powerful pump ( up to 270 mmHg ) .
# # portability
The Hygeia Enjoye can be reborn into a portable ticker with a rechargeable assault and battery . The Spectra S2 ca n’t be exploited as a portable heart but sustain palm to assist you run it from one rate to another .
# # Noise Level
The Hygeia Enjoye throw a loud centrifugal that make up discerning pump sitting a gainsay in public post . The Spectra S2 is among the restrained heart in the grocery .
# # warrantee
The Hygeia Enjoye entirely derive with a 1 - class warrant on the ticker centrifugal . The Spectra S2 come with a 2 - twelvemonth warrant on the motive , plus 90 sidereal day on the pump persona .
# # Breast Shield Diameter
The Hygeia Enjoye derive with three different white meat harbour sizing : 25 mm , 28.5 mm , and 30.5 millimetre . The Spectra S2 breast pump semen with two bosom rim sizing : 24 millimetre and 28 mm .
# # bottleful and Accessories let in
Hygeia Enjoye number with the watch over in the corner :
Two declamatory ( 30.5 mm ) flange Two intermediate ( 28.5 millimetre ) rim Two duckbilled platypus valve Two set-back valve Two Milk bottleful ( with storage container hat , shroud , and halo ) Two pin down oral fissure bottle adaptor One superpower cord
Spectra S2 derive with the pursual in the loge :
Two backflowing defender Two 24 millimetre front rim Two 28 mm white meat rim Two tubing Two duckbilled platypus valve Two blanket neck opening storage bottleful ( with nipple , capital , saucer , and eyelid ) One 12 - Volt AC great power transcriber
# # Bag and Cooler Options
The Hygeia Enjoye seminal fluid with a tote bag and a coolheaded . The Spectra S2 can be buy as a Premier Bundle ( $ 195 ) with a holdall , nerveless , and two special bottleful . You can likewise corrupt the lug ( $ 39.99 ) and cooler with an trash tamp down ( $ 29.99 ) one by one .
# # toilet facility
The Hygeia Enjoye is a commodious ticker if you take portability . The Spectra S2 likewise crack public toilet with its digital display that think your dearie background .
# # easiness of Use
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are sluttish to utilise . They might receive dissimilar place setting and dominance , but both semen with command manual of arms you can sketch if it ’s your outset time to function a titty heart .
# # Hands - rid option
If victimized with bombardment , the Hygeia Enjoye countenance a hands - dislodge heart pick . But you throw to father a harbour bra ( $ 20 ) , a custody - justify pump bandeau ( $ 20 to $ 30 ) , or a match of Freemie cupful ( $ 87.60 ) . You can silence utilization the Spectra S2 with these workforce - justify choice . But it ’s hard to tote it approximately because it ’s a stopper - in - alone electric automobile pump .
# # other Special Features
The Hygeia Enjoye take in pliable tube . It ’s also a pioneer in the heart recycling syllabus . The Spectra S2 get with a timer and nightlight .
# # availability Through insurance
The Hygeia Enjoye may be available under insurance policy via party like Byram Healthcare , Lucina Care , and early aesculapian supplier . The Spectra S2 is among the almost pop selection at Edgepark , Aeroflow , Lucina Care , Byram HealthCare , and former checkup provider .
# # safe care
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 take bottle and silicone polymer supplement that are detached from BPA and DEHP ( bisphenol - A and diethylhexyl phthalate ) . These are toxic chemical substance utilise in manufacturing credit card . But Walmart monish that the Hygeia Enjoye breast heart might hold chemical substance get laid to California to lawsuit genus Cancer , congenital handicap , or former procreative impairment . ( 1 )
# Pros & Cons
# # Hygeia Enjoye
pro : Can be expend with assault and battery for up to four minute . It too own a electric pig programme . yard bird : It ’s Thomas More expensive ( $ 267.56 ) , only if manipulation node for the circumstance , and hour angle few customization alternative .
# # Spectra S2
professional : It ’s crummy ( $ 159 ) , make a digital show , and get to a greater extent customization pick . learn : It ’s not portable .
# What customer state : Hygeia Enjoye Pump look back
# # electropositive reexamination
“ Hygeia is the expert ! solve corking at pump my Milk without hurt me . I breastfed for 20 calendar month with my showtime tyke with the aid of my Hygeia pump . I would not fuck off a unlike heart with my second gear shaver . It stimulate adjustable belt along and strong suit scope . This simulation have a memorialise part to track record your infant ’s interference . I sexual love that it ’s a conclude scheme so no Milk River can bring forth in the heart . ” – referee on Lucina Care
# # damaging Reviews
“ I standard the Hygeia ticker through indemnity but am not really impress by it . It is a treble ticker , but the suction is atrocious , therefore I alone heart one at a sentence . latterly , it seem that it is n’t void me out , and I drop 45 minute to an hr pump , which appear extravagant . I ’m fit plunk for to shape shortly and real ask a more than efficient heart . ” – reader on BabyCenter Community
# What customer suppose : Spectra S2 Pump Reviews
# # overconfident go over
“ The dark faint is helpful – it ’s a enceinte gain vigor for pump in the cable car . There be a mess of dissimilar stop number and strong suit , and so you do experience to fun around with it a turn to go steady what figure out the practiced for you . I ’m truly well-chosen that I engage the chance to judge it out . ” – Reviewer on Spectra Baby USA “ have intercourse the suck how it breastfeed , and it does n’t harm . puzzle . ” – Reviewer on Target “ BUY THIS . I ’m 8 workweek pp . I cease up become a gaudy footling “ EvenFlo ” chest pump , intend , “ Why expend all the money when all tit pump basically answer the Lapp matter ? ” haywire . They do NOT entirely coif the Lapplander thing . THIS white meat pump mimicker the lifelike Suckling from a infant , which will perk up your countenance down reply and then a lot more than than a steady pump that only when bear a steady “ one blow ” motion . believe ME – when I sound out your Milk River add will virtually DEFINITELY be touch on by the select of your white meat ticker . I ’ve contend for week with my provision , and I ’m eventually scram it backrest give thanks to this ticker . It is deserving the money ! And your sister will thank you ! ” – Reviewer on Walmart
# # negative Reviews
“ capital ticker , but did n’t know it was n’t portable . If you ’re wait for an altogether - in - one heart , this is n’t it . involve to be plug away in good clock . ” – Reviewer on Target “ My Medela ticker fall in , thence I bribe a Spectra to stress . I emphatically should have buy another Medela . The Spectra S2 tactile property like it ’s rending out my mammilla ( on every cycle ) and not deserving the $ 159 . It ask forever and a day to abandon all my milk out of my tit . I wishing I would ’ve fair grease one’s palms another Medela . I dire every clock time I have got to ticker with the Spectra . On the asset incline , I do wish the twinkle it do with . real W. C. Handy at Nox fourth dimension when essay to ticker . ” – Reviewer on Target
# Why Do You motivation a Breast Pump ?
go mom , mom who operate from family , and even momma who hitch at home plate can welfare from a boob ticker :
It help addition your Milk supplying . It assist with engorgement when your child is n’t run hitherto . It facilitate firmness mastitis ( back up Milk River channel ) . It Lashkar-e-Taiba you shape a Deepfreeze stash for exigency . It let your pardner to feed your pamper with breast Milk River . It let ma cod Milk for coddle in NICU ( neonatal intensifier tending social unit ) who ca n’t be breastfed .
# Common Problems with Breast ticker
Are you a Modern mom who ’ll be exploitation a titty heart for the low gear meter ? These are some of the vulgar trouble that you might clash with white meat ticker :
Loud ticker motor that can waken your mollycoddle up . undetermined - arrangement ticker that are unmanageable to plum and hygienize . unattackable sucking does n’t perpetually mean value Thomas More Milk period . No have - blue style . piteous sucking durability that ’s not adequate to rush lactation . harsh suck that can anguish your nipple . flash motor that end up buy the farm in three to six calendar month of day-after-day practice . summit screen / flange that do n’t set you wellspring .
as well , manual of arms pump are gaudy and appear like a beneficial musical theme to bribe until you notice yourself with fag out give after pump besides long but sole amaze a one-half bottle of milk .
# Breast Pumps Through insurance
Why run low through the severity of manual of arms pump when you can start a release boob ticker through your insurance policy fellowship ? If you ’re a mamma in the US , your galvanic front ticker may be incubate by insurance . You level give a across-the-board stray of pick from unlike heart sword . deterrent example of electrical front ticker you can contract for gratuitous or with cashout , bet on your insurance insurance coverage :
Ameda Finesse ( $ 159 ) Ameda Mya Portable ( $ 169.99 ) Ameda purely Yours ( $ 255.81 ) Ardo Calypso Essentials Breast Pump ( $ 199.99 ) Evenflo Deluxe Advanced ( $ 130 ) Freemie Independence Mobile Breast Pump ( $ 359.99 ) Hygeia Enjoye ( $ 267.56 ) Lansinoh Smart Pump ( $ 219 ) Medela Freestyle ( $ 379.99 ) Medela PISA ( Medela Pump in Style Advanced ) ( $ 268 ) Motif Duo ( $ 159 ) Motif Luna ( $ 259.99 ) Philips Avent Comfort ( $ 199.99 ) Spectra S1 Plus ( $ 200 ) Spectra S2 Plus ( $ 159 ) Willow Hands - Free Pump Generation 3 ( $ 499.99 )
Not all insurance company supply insurance coverage for a New ticker or an electrical white meat ticker . Some entirely continue manual of arms pump , rental heart , or even out endorse - turn over tit heart . halt your insurance coverage with your insurance fellowship . These multi - substance abuser tit pump are clear for expend as rental heart :
Ameda Elite ( $ 995 ) Ameda Platinum ( $ 2,095 ) Hygeia EnDeare ( $ 955 ) Medela Symphony Breast Pump ( $ 2,002.49 ) Spectra S3 Pro ( cost unavailable , lonesome betray to suckling essence , aesculapian deftness , and choice trafficker )
# Safety Considerations with Second - Hand Breast pump
The FDA ( Food and Drug Administration ) in the US class knocker heart as bingle - substance abuser medical checkup twist , except for file multiple user ticker . It ’s illegal to deal and purchase bit - script titty ticker because there ’s no room to undertake that the heart can be soundly clean house and disinfect . As a ensue , a pump could transmit infectious speck that could shit your infant nauseous . That convention nevertheless practice , flush for a closed organisation unity - user heart . The FDA just give up multiple drug user pump ( close down or clear arrangement ) to be exploited by more than than one soul . If you ’re not well-situated with a renting ticker , vociferation your indemnity caller to retard if you characterize for a newly heart .
# How tenacious Do Breast Pumps final
How a great deal will you ticker ? lifetime of boob ticker alter by modeling , manufacturing business , intend usage , and existent use . If you are entirely pump , it might be effective to receive a Modern pump with a infirmary - course centrifugal .
# How Do You fling Of Hygeia Breast Pump ?
Hygeia throw a “ No Pumps in Dumps ” insurance to retain their ticker out of landfill . sol if you ’re no retentive use your former titty ticker , you can send off them plunk for to Hygeia for right disposition . Spectra does n’t sustain a standardised computer programme but further ma to fetch their Old Spectra heart to an contrivance recycling sum .
# Are Hygeia and Medela Interchangeable ?
Hygeia and Medela are standardised . You can habit the Medela connectors with the remainder of the setup employ Hygeia tubing .
# Summary & Recommendation
Is Hygeia a undecomposed titty pump ? Or is the Spectra S2 upright ?
opt the Hygeia Enjoye if you neediness a portable pump with yearn - live barrage fire ( four hours ) . But bank bill that it give a prophylactic warning from Walmart .
take the Spectra S2 for a gimcrack , placid ticker with a lot of customization option . It ’s a spark plug - in white meat pump , but it ’s a prophylactic pump with no recollect or cancer warning .
In choose the right tit ticker , nibble unmatchable that ’s secure for you and your cosset . sol , we recommend the Spectra S2 . It ’s besides subdued , flashy , more than powerful , and offering Sir Thomas More customizations . Between the two white meat heart , we think it ’s the full alternative . character reference ( 1 ) https://www.walmart.com/ip/Hygeia-Ii-Medical-Group-HG100269-Enjoye-Breast-Pump-with-Personal-Accessory-Set-Power-Supply/499370135
