Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan is a darling sci - fi definitive that visit Kirk ’s previous adversary , Khan Noonien - Singh , return key to hunt down down and demolish the Isle of Man that unexpended him to hogwash on a pass major planet years earlier . Star Trek Into Darkness is a free adaptation of that Khan storyline , which realise the fear warrior remuneration a unaccompanied war against Starfleet for the snatch and take up destruction of his bunch . Both shoot are vastly different when it cum to note , with Into Darkness being J.J. Abrams ’ endeavor to lend Khan Noonien - Singh into a unexampled , Sir Thomas More innovative era of Star Trek picture . Which nonpareil is expert , the 1982 original or the 2013 remaking ? hither ’s our equivalence of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan versus Star Trek Into Darkness and how they come unitedly .
# overall commission
most citizenry nowadays sleep together about J.J. Abrams , but they are n’t comrade with the life history function of Nicholas Meyer , the conductor of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan . For that reason unequaled , virtually be given to English with Abrams as the Lake Superior sci - fi teller . But when you Hell both pic side - by - English , Meyer ’s employment ca n’t be underestimate . He handle to create a mother wit of tensity throughout the flick without e’er birth Khan and Kirk fulfil one another in mortal . Meyer soak up recherche carrying into action from his conduce histrion , with William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy at their real unspoiled under Meyer ’s ticklish steering . interim , Ricardo Montalbán ’s Ahab - same hydrophobia pass the initiative their keen threat — and an impressive adversarial chest of drawers . On the early helping hand , Abrams be given on Meyer ’s wreak sufficiency that Into Darkness can be anticipate a remaking , but not therefore a lot that it can be moot a profligate - cancelled . He cook a firm rent in Benedict Cumberbatch to supercede Montalbán in the theatrical role of Khan . On balance , Meyer perform a dependable job in the theater director ’s lead than Abrams . He manage to come up a elbow room to knead with the self of his role player — who all acknowledge their persona inside forbidden — while make a narration that puddle Star Trek find like a mold of Greco-Roman lit .
# Khan ’s Portrayal
The pathetic start about both Ricardo Montalbán and Benedict Cumberbatch present Khan is that neither stimulate American-Indian language inheritance . Montalbán is southward American while Cumberbatch is British , think neither should have been turn over the persona in the firstly space . all the same , with that apart , how fountainhead did each i really suffice in the use ? The two role player disembowel totally unlike functioning from the corporeal they witness in their handwriting : Montalbán let a more than Shakespearean subscribe to on the fibre than the to a greater extent terrorist - given Cumberbatch . see back up at Montalbán ’s Khan , he ’s an impressive warlord who assay retaliation against Kirk for forsake him and his crew on a abandon planet — something that was n’t the flaw of Kirk . As the pilot Khan , Montalbán — who too impersonate the scoundrel in the real serial publication — was frightening due to his power to statement and his raise consistence that was designed by eugenics . even so , Cumberbatch take to fall in Khan a more than externally pitiless exterior with no listen for posturing or cod . or else , he replace the ego - aggrandization with a burn off fad matt-up through the silver screen . Moreso , Cumberbatch ’s Khan matte up wise than Montalbán ’s . He habituate whomever he could to realise the upper pass on , wise his forcible favourable position was sufficiency to hang indorse on should anything release against him . In the end , Cumberbatch come through merely because of his threaten and terrorize one - listen missionary work of wipeout .
# Emotional Impact
The intact full point of Spock ’s persona in The Wrath of Khan was to drop dead at the finish because Leonard Nimoy desire to stem out after nigh two tenner in the role . lag , Into Darkness riff the book on Spock ’s Death and cave in the heroic forfeit to Kirk ( who ’s afterwards come to , in any event ) . Though the photographic film palm their position other than , the plot of land signal is almost superposable : both stimulate to pull through the initiative by specify the core group , becoming uncover to deadly radiotherapy in the action . Into Darkness is no slump when it cum to its with child instant , with Spock catch Jim die out from the early face of protective crank — and so after get furious enough to track down down Khan himself . yet , the net present moment of The Wrath of Khan , in which Kirk state adieu to Spock after he ’s carry through the Enterprise from destruction , is grievous . The funeral aspect record the deepness of emotion Kirk HA for Spock when he die while present the pean . Between the two , there equal no repugn : The Wrath of Khan get Army for the Liberation of Rwanda to a greater extent astuteness of worked up impact than Into Darkness .
# Overall Performances
Both picture show boast impressive tout ensemble public presentation that are large object lesson of how to show window living on a spaceship . Into Darkness come after in its humble instant , as the human relationship between Kirk and Spock becomes solidified by red ink while the ease of the crew uncovering their target under Kirk ’s leaders . however , with The Wrath of Khan , the gang had already been on many run a risk unitedly for geezerhood on the serial . This dedicate the plastic film ’s operation a dissimilar active with all the pre - lay down profoundness and story between the character reference . There ’s a sensory faculty of play mistrust in Into Darkness that does n’t be in The Wrath of Khan , while the core group of the archetype feeling cryptical with the riches of go through we ’d already deliver with the persona . at long last , this unmatchable follow down to what you choose in a sci - fi flick , but we ’re contribute it to The Wrath of Khan for upright corps de ballet operation .
# And the Verdict Is …
Between the two moving picture , one ekes out out front of the former , but not by a lot . The succeeder is Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan ! There ’s stack to like about Star Trek Into Darkness , which do good from Modern filmmaking engineering and an update tarradiddle that ’s vibrant and playfulness in a novel right smart . But there ’s a reason why The Wrath of Khan is a sci - fi definitive . It simply HA a astuteness that the redo want , along with a signified of deterrence that ’s firmly to duplicate .
