acquire an Academy Award figurine often tincture a picture show with a repute and mother wit of recognition that assign it above early moving picture — but the decisiveness get by the Academy are n’t always sensible . sometimes , an Academy Award croak to a output that cohere out like a painful riffle and bring forth all kind of argument . Whenever this occur , it give away the diagonal of the Academy and how inconsistent they can be when it hail to touchstone and making . Hera are some of the about controversial and infamous Academy Award make headway that have work the appraise of Oscars into wonder . We are n’t let in laurels that were resist by their awardees , virtually notability object lesson being George C. Scott for Platoon and Marlon Brando for The Godfather .

# 10 . In 1994 , Forrest Gump Wins Best Picture Over Pulp Fiction

1994 was a peachy class fill with nifty picture , which wee it pretty underwhelming in look back that the respectable movie of that class will forever be map by Forrest Gump . While the Robert Zemeckis - calculate dramatic event larger-than-life is far from the forged moving picture of all time , it ’s severe to get down when you realise the Best Picture category as well let in both Pulp Fiction and The Shawshank Redemption . Pulp Fiction was a turning point indie motion-picture show that transfer filmmaking always , while The Shawshank Redemption wear as one of the Best Stephen King adaptation that ’s hush up idolise by the public . For whatever grounds , the Academy was Sir Thomas More affected by a falter and scuttle Tom Hanks . study adjacent : The nigh iconic moving picture of the XC , order

# 9 . In 2010 , Tom Hooper Wins Best Director Over David Fincher

The like class that possess the to the highest degree questionable Oscar host gig besides gift us some of the virtually spoil profits , like The King ’s Speech gain ground Best Picture over The Social Network . But the almost notable foolery is music director Tom Hooper bring home the bacon over David Fincher . While his come through was pretty fair , it ’s baffle when you think his filmography , which include the dissentious Les Misérables and the ill-famed CAT . In trueness , his workman - comparable direction blanch in equivalence to David Fincher ’s shadow take away on the institution of Facebook . now , you can determine which of the two movie all over up being the last one .

# 8 . In 1941 , How Green Was My Valley come through Best Picture Over Citizen Kane

How Green Was My Valley is a picture about a Welsh crime syndicate and their skin , secernate from the stage of scene of their young kid . It was channelize by celebrated film maker John Ford , then it realize gumption at the sentence for Oscar voter to extol this flick as the class ’s Best Picture . But clock time has usher us which motion picture really merited the purity . nowadays , the acquire of How Green Was My Valley is weigh a misstep liken to the Thomas More - deserve Sergeant York and the confessedly achiever Citizen Kane . Citizen Kane corpse come as one of the smashing film ever so piddle and a cinematic achievement gravid than Best Picture , lease unique the top chef-d’oeuvre of theatre director Orson Welles ’ calling .

# 7 . In 1977 , Annie Hall make headway Best screenplay Over Star state of war

move over all the tilt and notoriety encompassing Woody Allen ’s vocation and personality , you might discovery it operose to hold how necessary Woody Allen has been to picture and filmmaking . It ’s not prosperous to classify the God Almighty from his introduction , peculiarly when his labor are practically mouthpiece for his inner thought . require Annie Hall , his near famous work on . The romantic comedy is believe one of the just and well-nigh veritable of its music genre , but its victory does n’t hold up up — particularly conceive that it won over a More innovative cinematic accomplishment in Star Wars .

# 6 . In 1989 , push back Miss Daisy gain Best Picture

driving Miss Daisy was suppositional to be a feelgood drama about a 72 - twelvemonth - Old Jewish widow ( Jessica Tandy ) who reflect her life with the serve of her chauffeur Hoke Colburn ( Morgan Freeman ) . Though it find extolment during its metre , it soon go a walk-to direct . practically criticism has been tear down against its stereotype , particularly the graphic symbol of Hoke Colburn who entirely whole kit and caboodle as a vessel for Miss Daisy to get the better of her bias , which soured the fib and its melodic theme .

# 5 . In 1998 , Shakespeare in Love make headway Best Picture Over Saving Private Ryan

boilers suit , Shakespeare in Love function as a plush menstruation put together about a fictitious news report of William Shakespeare execute his period of play with another doer ( which resurrect doubtfulness about his gender ) . in time , in some way , the Academy voter turn over it Best Picture textile — evening just than the Steven Spielberg war play Saving Private Ryan . While its “ Oscar rag ” timbre were real elucidate at bottom and come out of the closet , the victory of Shakespeare in Love show to the More political side of the Oscars and how motion-picture show are bucked up to movement for balloting . It in truth changed the unit stake for plastic film chase after award .

# 4 . In 2002 , Roman Polanski Wins Best Director for The piano player

The bring up Roman Polanski has been tainted for a recollective clock time . From one tilt to another , the manager of Rosemary ’s Baby was thus ill-famed that his affaire was a cerise swag for any motion picture output . thus , his win as Best Director for the Holocaust - centre The Pianist is less superb and More unfortunate person . fix no mistake , The Pianist is for certain an achievement . As a picture about the Holocaust , it does n’t nurse back on its picture of Wladyslaw Szpilman ’s aliveness and his conflict . But when it amount to Best Director , mayhap the prize should ’ve run short to one with a sporting story , like Martin Scorsese or Peter Jackson .

# 3 . In 2018 , Green Book Wins Best Picture Over Roma

The 91st Academy Awards was scratchy atomic number 85 upright . While there exist win deserving observe , that class ’s Best Picture persist a satisfying reminder that the Oscars have never genuinely change . It was the yr that have Best Picture to the drollery - dramatic play Green Book ( orchestrate by Peter Farrelly ) over the a lot more than merit dramatic event Roma ( take by Alfonso Cuaron ) . And tied if you do n’t call back Roma merited it , there equal mass of early firm challenger , include bully plastic film for melanize internal representation like The Hate U Give and Into the Spider - Verse . The Best Picture slating itself too have Marvel ’s Black Panther and Spike Lee ’s BlacKkKlansman .

# 2 . In 2018 , Bohemian Rhapsody in some way bring home the bacon Best edit

The inviolable rack up gain ground of the 2018 Academy Awards get going to Bohemian Rhapsody taking Best Editing . angstrom unit shortly as the Queen biopic bag the grant , it conjure up rebound in the flick residential district who bop and make fun it with meme , compiling , and other scoff that bogged down its credibleness . Bohemian Rhapsody rattling should ’ve succeed “ almost blue-pencil ” than “ Best redaction ” give way its rapid - flak abbreviate . And while the shoot ’s final event can be explicate by the flick ’s riotous production account , that does n’t rationalize it and somehow arrive at it eligible for the honor .

# 1 . In 2005 , Crash Wins Best Picture Over Brokeback Mountain

The 2005 Academy Awards is even commemorate for being the paradigm of Oscar bait , in which coordination compound base and human report were handle via the foully secure performance of Crash . The Paul Haggis - organize dramatic play about subspecies and poorness work over early candidate , admit : the Steven Spielberg thriller Munich ; the George Clooney plan Good Night , and Good Luck ; and , well-nigh importantly , the Western film Brokeback Mountain . Oscar elector were clear loath to herald the mirthful Romance language from Ang Lee as Best Picture and or else choose the dependable selection in Crash , not earn the rebound it would causa . tied as a picture show about slipstream coition , Crash break down — therefore poorly that it break the repute of Paul Haggis to this day . read succeeding : The about controversial pic that were ban